Clarity Act Failed: How Regulators Are Writing Crypto Rules Now
After the Clarity Act's 49-50 Senate defeat, the SEC and CFTC are issuing crypto rules piece by piece. What each step is, how durable it is, and what to watch.

Key takeaways
- The Clarity Act failed a 49-50 cloture vote on the motion to proceed on September 15, 2026. It needed 60 votes, and no new law was created.
- The Block reported that Senator Thom Tillis asked to enter a motion to reconsider, which keeps a later vote possible. As of October 14, 2026, no second vote had taken place.
- Any bill not enacted before this Congress ends on January 3, 2027 expires, so time for a second Senate vote is limited.
- Since the vote, the SEC has issued a temporary innovation exemption for tokenized stocks and proposed custody rules. The CFTC has published an advance notice that only asks questions. According to CoinDesk, SEC Chair Paul Atkins has said such agency rules won't be durable without a law behind them.
- Before reacting to any crypto rule headline, ask three things: is it law, a final rule or a draft; does it have an end date; and does it cover what you actually hold?
The Clarity Act, the US crypto market structure bill, is still not law. A Senate vote to start work on it failed 49-50 on September 15, 2026, short of the 60 votes needed. Since then, the SEC and CFTC have issued crypto measures piece by piece, each with a different level of legal strength.
For XRP holders, the key point is that the failed vote did not change the federal rules your coins sat under. The video argues that the new agency steps are easier to change than a law would be. Knowing which rules are final and which are drafts helps you read headlines without overreacting.
What did the Senate actually vote on?
The Senate did not vote on the Clarity Act itself. It voted on cloture on the motion to proceed to H.R. 3633, the Clarity Act. A motion to proceed is a vote to start working on a bill. Cloture is the step that limits debate so a vote can happen. Because the cloture vote failed, the Senate did not formally begin debate on the bill.
The Senate’s roll call records the result as rejected: 49 yes, 50 no and one senator not voting. The vote needed three-fifths, which is 60 votes in a full Senate. The bill missed 60 and also missed a simple majority. The roll call shows senators from both parties among the no votes. The bill’s official title describes a system for regulating the offer and sale of digital commodities by the SEC and the CFTC.
Why did the Clarity Act stall?
CoinDesk reported that the last open sections included ethics rules meant to stop senior government officials from keeping crypto business ties. According to CoinDesk, those sections produced rifts that negotiators could not close. The Block reported that Senator Catherine Cortez Masto of Nevada objected to the bill. She said it would undermine law enforcement’s ability to go after bad actors and did not do enough on ethics.
Other senators saw it differently. CoinDesk calls Senator Cynthia Lummis of Wyoming the leading Republican negotiator. According to the video, she urged a yes vote on the floor, saying: “Do not let this day be the day we handed our future to someone else because we were too afraid to finish what we started.” According to The Block, Patrick Witt, then the White House crypto adviser, called the result a major disappointment.
Is there going to be another Senate vote?
No second vote had happened as of October 14, 2026, when the Bullrunners team checked the Senate’s vote list. Reports from early November said there still had not been one. The Block reported that Senator Thom Tillis of North Carolina first voted yes, then changed his vote to no and asked to enter a motion to reconsider. That procedural step leaves room for a later vote. The video also says The Block reported a post on X in which Tillis said this is not the end for the Clarity Act. Bullrunners has not been able to find that post itself.
The clock matters too. A bill that is not enacted by the end of a two-year Congress expires. This Congress ends on January 3, 2027. The video does not guess whether or when another vote will come. For more on the procedure, see what the motion to reconsider means.
Who sets crypto rules without a new law?
Without a new law, the SEC and the CFTC are setting crypto rules under their existing powers, one step at a time. According to CoinDesk, SEC Chair Paul Atkins has said the agency’s new crypto rules and exemptions won’t be durable without a law underpinning them. In other words, the head of the SEC himself says these rules need legislation behind them to last.
The video describes the rules as a ladder, with each rung carrying a different weight:
| Rung | What it means | Example since the vote |
|---|---|---|
| Law | Passed by Congress and signed | None. The Clarity Act failed |
| Final rule | Adopted by an agency, in force | None covered in the video |
| Proposal | Proposed, not final, open for public comment | SEC custody proposal, October 1 |
| Advance notice | Agency still asking questions before proposing | CFTC notice, October 5 |
Temporary exemptions sit off to the side of the ladder rather than on a rung. They give relief now, but they come with an end date built in. The SEC’s innovation exemption of September 17 is one example.
What have the SEC and CFTC done since the vote?
The agencies have taken three steps since the vote, and each has a different strength:
- September 17: SEC innovation exemption. Two days after the vote, the SEC announced what it calls the innovation exemption. Its release describes the exemption as temporary, conditional, exemptive relief. It lets venues the SEC calls tokenized security venues trade tokenized versions of listed US stocks. It covers stocks issued as tokens, not coins like Bitcoin or Ether, and is set to expire five years after publication.
- October 1: SEC custody proposal. The SEC proposed new custody rules for investment advisers and funds. The proposal would let state trust companies act as custodians and would allow crypto to be held in self-custody under certain circumstances. It is proposed, not final. Comments are open for 60 days after publication in the Federal Register. According to the video, Atkins spoke in the release of uncertainty created by custody rules crafted in a bygone era. Our explainer on who owns your XRP under the custody proposal covers what self-custody means in that document.
- October 5: CFTC advance notice. The CFTC published an advance notice of proposed rulemaking, which is a set of questions an agency asks before it proposes a rule. CoinDesk says the notice seeks feedback on leveraged retail crypto trading and a new registration category. Comments are due within 60 days of the notice appearing in the Federal Register. The video quotes CFTC Chair Michael Selig calling the notice a critical step in the agency’s efforts to keep America the crypto capital of the world.
What is still uncovered?
According to a CoinDesk analysis published on October 11, ordinary spot trading still lacks comprehensive federal oversight beyond the CFTC’s anti-fraud and anti-manipulation powers. Spot trading means buying a coin outright with no borrowed money. The video notes that this is CoinDesk’s analysis, not an official finding. CoinDesk said parts of the article were written with help from AI tools and reviewed by its editors. CoinDesk also discloses that it is part of Bullish, a crypto company, and that its staff may be paid partly in Bullish stock.
Views on the agency approach differ. Kristin Smith, president of the Solana Policy Institute, told The Block that the SEC and CFTC have kept moving on crypto policy for the last year and a half. Derek Lowry, head of legal at Newton Labs, told CoinDesk “the biggest gap is implementation.” A general counsel quoted by CoinDesk said agency action is welcome but “does not provide the same long-term certainty as legislation.”
For a closer look at the XRP side of the story, see what changed for XRP holders after the vote.
Three questions to ask about any crypto rule
The video offers a simple check for any rule headline:
- Is it law, a final rule or a draft? Read the first lines of the official release for words like proposed, final or advance notice. If a news story doesn’t say, the agency’s release will.
- Does it have an end date? Look for the words temporary or expire, and note the date.
- Does it cover what you actually hold or do? A rule for tokenized stocks, or for advisers and funds, may not touch coins you hold yourself.
The video illustrates this with two made-up holders. One treats every headline as all-or-nothing. The other asks where the news sits on the ladder, notices the word proposed on the custody rule, and waits for the final version. Neither moves any money. The difference is how clearly each one understands the news.
The video is open about its limits. The roll call shows how senators voted, not why. Several details come from a single outlet. Proposals can change before they become final. The coverage is US federal only, and the pages were checked on October 14.
What to watch next
- The motion to reconsider. Whether the Senate takes it up before this Congress ends on January 3, 2027.
- Federal Register dates. Check federalregister.gov for when the SEC custody proposal and the CFTC notice were published, because publication starts each 60-day comment clock. One report suggested the custody proposal was due to be published soon after its release, so that clock may already be running.
- The SEC custody rule. Whether the proposal becomes a final rule, and what changes along the way.
- The CFTC’s next step. Whether it moves from asking questions to proposing actual rules.
The video’s read would change if Congress passed a market structure law, if the agencies finalized rules that cover spot trading, or if the temporary exemption were made permanent. None of the items above is about price. They are about which crypto rules are settled and which are still being written.
Frequently asked questions
Did the Clarity Act become law?
No. On September 15, 2026, the Senate rejected a cloture vote on the motion to proceed to the Clarity Act, 49-50, when 60 votes were needed. When Bullrunners checked the Senate's vote list on October 14, there had been no second vote.
Is the Clarity Act dead?
Not formally, but time is short. The Block reported that Senator Thom Tillis asked to enter a motion to reconsider, which keeps a later vote possible. Any bill not enacted before this Congress ends on January 3, 2027 expires.
What is the SEC's innovation exemption?
The SEC describes it as temporary, conditional, exemptive relief that lets tokenized security venues trade tokenized versions of listed US stocks. It covers stocks issued as tokens, not coins like Bitcoin or Ether, and is set to expire five years after publication.
Does the SEC custody proposal apply to my personal wallet?
Probably not directly. The October 1, 2026 proposal covers investment advisers and funds, and the video notes that rules for advisers and funds may not touch coins you hold yourself. It is still only a proposal, open for comment for 60 days after publication in the Federal Register.
What did the CFTC do after the Clarity Act vote?
On October 5, 2026, the CFTC issued an advance notice of proposed rulemaking, which is a set of questions an agency asks before it proposes any rule. CoinDesk says the notice seeks feedback on leveraged retail crypto trading and a new registration category.
Full video transcript
From the video's captions, lightly formatted. Captions can mishear names and numbers, so check figures against the article above.
On the 15th of September, the United States Senate voted on whether to move ahead with the Clarity Act, a bill that would set federal rules for crypto market. The Senate's own roll call records the result as rejected, 49 votes to 50. Now, CoinDesk's headline that afternoon said that the bill flamed out. Maybe you saw a headline like that and couldn't tell if crypto just got stricter rules or no rules at all. Or maybe you've read about new crypto rules for months and still can't say which ones are actually enforced.
Now, that isn't bad luck. You just weren't shown which rules are final and which are just still drafts. Today, we'll read the vote from the Senate's own record, look at what the agencies did next, and sort out what settled and what isn't. And you'll get three questions to ask about any crypto rule you hear about.
[music]
If you hold a serious position, $50,000 or more, stick around because at that size, it pays to know which rules are settled and which are still being written. First things first, this video is for education, not financial advice or legal advice. We're reporting the vote and what officials said, not taking a political side, and not guessing what Congress does next. Now, here's the route. First, the vote and what it actually decided.
Then, why 60 matters. Then, why it stalled, what it means for your money, and what the agencies are doing, and then finally what to watch. So, if you're feeling bullish and you'd rather read the record than the reaction, hit the like button. And if you're going to become the first millionaire in your family tree, confirm it by subscribing and commenting amen below. But, let's get straight into it.
All right, bull runners, welcome back to the channel. So, what did the Senate actually vote on? The roll call lists the bill as HR 3633. Its title on the Senate's page begins with a long sentence: To provide for a system of regulation of the offer and sale of digital commodities by the Securities and Exchange Commission and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission. Now, in plain English, the bill set out how two federal agencies, the SEC and the CFTC, would oversee crypto.
But, here's the detail that's easy to miss. The Senate didn't vote on the bill itself. The question on the roll call was cloture on the motion to proceed. Now, a motion to proceed is a vote to start working on a bill. Cloture is the step that limits debate so that a vote can actually happen.
So, this was a vote on whether to start, not a final vote on the law. And because it failed, the Senate didn't formally start debate on the bill that day. So, why does 60 keep coming up? The roll call says this vote needed 3/5 to pass. Now, with a full Senate of 100, 3/5 is 60 votes.
The result was 49 yes and 50 no, and one Senate not voted. So, the bill didn't reach 60 and it didn't reach a simple majority, either. CoinDesk put it this way. The bill fell far short in rounding up the 60 supports required to advance. The roll call also shows Senate's from both parties among the no votes.
So, why did it stall? CoinDesk reported that the last open sections included ethics rules meant to curtail senior government officials from maintaining crypto business ties. It says those sections turned out to feature insurmountable rips. The Block, a crypto news outlet, also reported the 49 to 50 result. It reported that Senator Catherine Cortez Masto of Nevada had objections to the bill.
She said it would undermine law enforcement's ability to go after bad actors and that it didn't do enough on ethics. Now, those are her views as The Block reported them and other senators saw the bill differently. Senator Cynthia Lummis of Wyoming, who CoinDesk calls the leading Republican negotiator, urged a yes vote on the floor. She said, "Do not let this day be the day we handed our future to someone else because we were too afraid to finish what we started." Then, something happened that's easy to miss. The Block reports Senator Thom Tillis of North Carolina first voted yes, then changed his vote to no.
It says he didn't ask to enter a motion to reconsider, which leaves room for a later Senate vote. Now, in a post on X, The Block reports he said this is not the end for the clarity. Now, when we checked the Senate's vote list on the 14th of October, there was no second vote on this bill. The latest vote on that list was from the 13th of September. Now, we're not going to guess whether or when another vote comes, but Patrick Witt, the White House crypto advisor, called the result a major disappointment, according to The Block.
So, with no new law, who sets the rules? Coindesk reports SEC Chairman Paul Atkins has said the agency's new crypto rules and exemptions won't be durable without a law underpinning them. Now, durable just means lasting. So, the head of the SEC has himself said that the agency rules need a law behind them to last. Now, that's the chairman of the SEC talking about his own agency's work, as Coindesk reports it.
So, what does a failed Senate vote mean for the money that you actually hold? First, the vote didn't create a new law, so it didn't change the federal rules that your coin sat under on that day. Second, the rules now coming out come from agencies one piece at a time. And third, those pieces aren't all the same strength. You have to picture it like a ladder.
At the top is a law passed by Congress and signed. Below that is a final rule from an agency. Below that is a proposal, which is proposed, not final, and open for public comment. Below that is an advanced notice where an agency is still asking questions. And off to the side sits temporary exemptions, which come with an end date.
So, when you read that crypto has a new rule, the first job is to find out which rung you're looking at. And here's where this hits home. Maybe you've read about a new crypto rule and treated it as self without checking whether it was only a proposal. Or you read that a bill failed and figured it meant nothing for you either way. And if you're quietly thinking, I've been doing this wrong, that's a fair thing to feel.
Headlines don't always say which rung a rule sits on, and agency releases are long and dense. Missing that detail doesn't make you a careless investor. So, a quick check. For the crypto rules you've heard about this year, could you say which are law, which are final, and which are still draft? Now, we tell our private intelligence network members get our research first, including what each new rule is and where it stands.
We also go through idle crypto and self-custody with members, one setup at a time. Add weekly chart sessions and long-term holders comparing notes, so you're not decoding agency releases by yourself. Imagine this, a headline says crypto has a new rule and within a minute you know whether it's a law, a final rule, or a draft still taking comments. Now, if a free review of how your crypto is set up would help, the first link in the description goes to Altcoin Pro, the company we co-founded. It looks at custody, how much sits with any one coin or platform, and idle crypto.
So, click the first link in the description, watch the free briefing, and book your free portfolio review. We won't ask for your seed phrase or any password. And if it doesn't fit your situation, we'll tell you so on the call. Now, crypto carries risk and past performance doesn't guarantee future results. This is education, not financial advice.
Back to the agency. Now, 2 days after the vote, the SEC announced something it calls the innovation exemption. The SEC's release describes it as temporary, conditional, exemptive relief. It's for trading venues the SEC calls tokenized security venues to trade tokenized version of listed US stocks. So, it's about stocks issued as tokens, not about coins like Bitcoin or Ether.
And the SEC says it's set to expire 5 years after publication. Atkins said in a release that the exemption, while temporary, would allow those venues to trade tokenized stock. And that's the side tag on your ladder, a rung with an end date built in. Then on the 1st of October, the SEC proposed new custody rules for investment advisers and funds. Its release says the proposal would let state trust companies act as custodians.
And it would permit crypto assets to be held in self-custody under certain circumstances. Now, this one is proposed, not final. The SEC says comments are open for 60 days after the proposal was published in the Federal Register. So, if you hold crypto through an adviser or a fund, this could matter to you, but for now it's just a draft. And in the release, Atkins spoke of the gray of uncertainty created by custody rules crafted by a bygone era.
On the 5th of October, the CFTC took an earlier step. It put out an advanced notice of proposed rule making, which is a set of questions an agency asks before it even proposes a rule. CoinDesk describes it as asking for feedback on rules for leveraged retail crypto trading and a new registration category. The CFTC says comments are due within 60 days of the notice appearing in the Federal Register. The CFTC's chairman, Michael Selig, called it a critical step in the agency's efforts to ensure America remains the crypto capital of the world.
Now, that's the bottom rung of our ladder. Questions, not rules yet. So, what's still open? A CoinDesk analysis on the 11th of October pointed to a gap. It said ordinary unleveraged spot trading still lacks comprehensive federal oversight beyond the CFTC's anti-fraud and anti-manipulation powers.
Spot trading just means buying a coin outright with no borrowed money. And that's CoinDesk's analysis and the article notes parts of it were written with help from AI tools and reviewed by its editors. One note on CoinDesk, it says it's part of Bullish, a crypto company, and its staff may be paid partly in Bullish stock. Now, here's a made-up example to show you how this plays out. Holder A and Holder B both see the same alert.
Senate rejects crypto bill. Holder A decides it either changes all of crypto or none of it and simply moves on. Holder B asks to one thing, which rung of the ladder is this? A few weeks later, both see a new alert about custody proposal. Holder A treats it as a done deal.
Holder B sees the word proposed, notes that comments are open, and waits for the final version. Now, neither of them has done anything with their money in this example. The difference is how clearly each one understands what the news actually is. Now, where our information stops. One, the roll call shows how senators voted, not why, so the reasons come from news reports and statements.
Two, several details come from one outlet each and we've said which outlet each time. Three, the agency steps up proposals and advanced notice or a temporary exemption and final versions could look completely different. Four, the gap in spot trading oversight is CoinDesk's analysis, not an official finding. Five, this covers United States federal rules only, and states and other countries have their own. And six, we check these pages on the 14th of October, and things that can change after that.
So, what would show that we've got this all wrong? Now, our read is simple. Without a law, the federal rules for crypto stay partial, and the agency pieces are easier to change. So, if Congress passed a market structure law, the top rung of the ladder would be filled, and this picture would change. Now, if the agencies turned their proposals into final rules that covered spot trading, the gap CoinDesk describes would shrink.
And if the temporary exemption were made permanent, that end date would no longer apply. Now, in fairness, agency work isn't nothing. Kristin Smith, president of the Solana Policy Institute, told The Block that the SEC and CFTC have kept moving on crypto policy for the last year and a half. And Derek Lowry, head of legal at Newton Labs, told CoinDesk, "The biggest gap is implementation." The caution comes from Kevin Crouse, general counsel at the firm D-Free, told CoinDesk, "The agency action is welcome, but it does not provide the same long-term certainty as legislation." And here's what's worth watching. First, whether the motion to reconsider The Block reported is ever taken up, without us guessing when.
Second, the dates the custody proposal in the CFTC notice appear in the Federal Register, because that starts their 60-day comment clocks. Third, whether the SEC's custody proposal becomes a final rule, and what changes along the way. And finally, fourth, whether the CFTC moves from asking questions to proposing actual rules. Now, none of these four is about the price of any coin, and that isn't what this video covers. We're looking at which rules are settled and which are still being written.
And here's the short version. The Senate's roll call shows the motion to move ahead with the Clarity Act was rejected, 49 to 50, and when 60 votes were needed. Since then, the SEC has issued a temporary exemption for tokenized stocks and proposed new custody rules. And the CFTC has published an advance notice, which asks questions and isn't a proposed rule. Time for the three rule questions I promised you at the start.
Question one, is it law, a final rule, or a draft? Look at the first lines of the official release for words like proposed, final, or advanced notice. If a news story doesn't say, the agency's own release will. Question two, does it have an end date? Now, look for the words temporary or expire, and note the date next to the rule.
Question three, does it cover what you actually hold or do? A rule for tokenized stocks or for advisers and funds may not touch coins you hold yourself. But, this is about knowing which rules apply to you, not about moving your money anywhere. Those three come straight from the story, the rung, the end date, and who the rule is for. So, put simply, a failed vote didn't change the law, and the new agency pieces each sit on a different rung.
So, when you hear crypto has a new rule, ask which rung it's on. Now, one last thing, knowing which rules are final deserves as much attention as knowing which coins you own. Now, if you're holding a meaningful stack and you're not sure which rules touch it, we built this for that. Inside our private intelligence network, we go through new rules with members as they come out, with other long-term holders alongside. On the review call, there are no price promises and no buy or sell calls, and we won't point you towards any coin, platform, or political view.
Click the first link in the description, watch the free briefing, and book your free portfolio review. We won't ask for your seed phrase or any passwords. If it doesn't fit your situation, we'll tell you so on the call. Crypto carries risk, and past performance doesn't guarantee future results. This is education, not financial advice.
I will see you at the top. As always, you know what to do. Stay bullish.
Education and commentary only, not financial advice. Crypto is volatile and you can lose money. Do your own research and speak to a qualified advisor before making investment decisions. Figures and quotes are as reported in the video on October 18, 2026 and may have changed since.


