Monero's Origin Story: The Fork, the Privacy Tech and the Risks
How Monero began with a pseudonymous white paper and a fork away from its founder, how its privacy works, and why exchanges and EU rules keep squeezing it.

Key takeaways
- Monero launched in April 2014 as BitMonero, and within weeks Riccardo Spagni and six others forked the project away from its original launcher.
- Monero has no company, no chief executive and no pre-mine; every coin was created by public mining, and developers are funded through community crowdfunding.
- Monero hides the sender, the receiver and the amount using ring signatures, one-time stealth addresses and RingCT.
- Exchange delistings, the August 2025 Qubic mining episode and EU anti-money laundering rules from July 2027 are real risks for anyone holding XMR.
- For any coin you hold, ask who got the coins first, who could change the rules, and how regulators might affect where it trades.
Monero (XMR) began in April 2014 as BitMonero, a coin built on the pseudonymous CryptoNote white paper and launched on a forum by a user called thankful_for_today. Within weeks, Riccardo Spagni and six others forked the project away from him, leaving Monero with no company, no chief executive and no founder in control.
That origin story matters to holders of any coin, not only Monero. The video, presented by George Lee, uses it to raise three questions worth asking about everything in a portfolio: who got the coins first, who can change the rules, and how regulators could limit where a coin trades.
Who wrote the Monero white paper?
The Monero white paper is CryptoNote, published under the name Nicolas van Saberhagen, a pseudonym nobody has ever proven belongs to a real, identified person. In a clip shown in the video, Riccardo Spagni says it is unknown whether the name covers one person or several, and that the first code was written by another pseudonym, Antonio Juarez.
CryptoNote is dated December 2012, with an updated version dated October 2013. Critics later argued those dates were fake. Its main idea was that Bitcoin’s open ledger, where anyone can follow the money, was a flaw rather than a feature. It combined techniques such as ring signatures and one-time addresses to make payments hard to link.
What was the Bytecoin pre-mine accusation?
The first coin to use CryptoNote was Bytecoin, and critics accused it of a hidden pre-mine. Bytecoin’s blockchain claimed to have started in 2012, but it only became publicly known in March 2014. Critics, including Spagni, argued its early history had been mined in secret and that roughly 80% of all coins that would ever exist were created before the public could mine any.
A pre-mine means insiders hold coins that cost them almost nothing and can sell them later to everyone else. The video compares it to raffle organizers quietly handing themselves most of the tickets before announcing the draw. The accusation against Bytecoin has never been proven either way, but it shaped what came next.
How was Monero taken from its own founder?
Monero was taken from its launcher through a fork, which in plain English means copying the code and carrying on without the original owner. On April 18, 2014, thankful_for_today launched BitMonero on Bitcoin Talk, starting from zero so nobody had a head start. According to the people who took over, he wanted changes the community didn’t support and wouldn’t listen.
In a 2018 talk shown in the video, Spagni says he and six others forked the project and became its “stewards,” which he describes as controlling the GitHub repository and the domain, and little else. The community version won within weeks and took the name Monero, which means coin in Esperanto.
That moment set the project’s structure. According to the video:
- Monero has no company, no chief executive and no founder who can pull the strings.
- Spagni stepped down as lead maintainer in December 2019, and the project carried on.
- No development fund is taken from each block. Developers post proposals on a community crowdfunding system and supporters donate to the ones they want built.
- There was no pre-mine. Every coin was created by public mining from day one.
How does Monero hide transactions?
Monero hides the sender, the receiver and the amount, all three of which are visible on Bitcoin. Spagni lists four privacy features in the video:
| Feature | What it hides | How it works |
|---|---|---|
| Stealth addresses | Where a payment goes | You share one public address, and each sender turns it into a new one-time address only you can recognize |
| Ring signatures | Who sent it | Your spend is mixed with decoys so observers only know one member of the group sent it |
| RingCT (Ring Confidential Transactions) | How much was sent | Observers can’t tell whether you sent five coins or 5,000 |
| Dandelion++ (added 2020) | The sender’s IP address | Hides where a transaction came from on the internet |
In a Monero community film shown in the video, Dr. Daniel Kim explains that ring signatures originally lined each sender up with 10 decoys, so all anyone could know was that one of 11 people sent the money. The video says Monero later raised that to 16, so each spend now hides among 15 decoys.
The video gives two reasons this matters. The first is privacy: Kim compares Bitcoin to a bank pinning your monthly statement on a public bulletin board. The second is fungibility, meaning every unit is interchangeable. On a transparent chain, a coin can carry its history, and some services may refuse coins that once passed through a hacked exchange, even years later. With Monero there is no visible history to refuse. For a comparison with another privacy coin’s design, see Bullrunners’ piece on the Zcash trusted setup ceremony.
How does Monero mining and supply work?
Monero is designed so ordinary computers can mine it, and it has no fixed supply cap. Spagni says in the video that Monero resists ASICs, the specialized mining machines that dominate Bitcoin, because the white paper named “egalitarian mining” as a goal. Monero changed its mining formula several times to keep those machines out, and in November 2019 switched to RandomX, designed to run best on ordinary processors.
In 2022 Monero also moved to a tail emission. Instead of stopping at a fixed cap, as described in what happens when all 21 million bitcoin are mined, Monero pays miners 0.6 XMR per block indefinitely. Supporters say this guarantees miners are always paid to secure the network even if fees stay low. Critics point out that the supply never stops growing, though the growth rate shrinks each year.
Why do exchanges and regulators keep pushing Monero out?
Monero’s privacy conflicts with rules that expect exchanges to know who their customers pay and are paid by. The video lists a series of pressure points:
- September 2020: the IRS offered up to $625,000 for tools to trace Monero.
- February 6, 2024: Binance said it would drop Monero. The Monero project’s account replied the same day.
- October 31, 2024: Kraken halted Monero trading in Europe.
- August 2025: a project called Qubic pointed large amounts of mining power at Monero and rewrote six blocks of its history. That is not the same as stealing coins, but it showed a well-funded group could push the network around. Kraken paused Monero deposits for a while afterward. Whether Qubic ever controlled more than half the mining power is still debated, the video notes.
- July 2027: under new EU anti-money laundering rules, banks, exchanges and other crypto firms in the EU won’t be allowed to handle coins like Monero.
The video also acknowledges that criminals use Monero, with researchers tracking it in ransomware demands and darknet markets. Supporters answer that cash is also used by criminals and remains legal. Andreas Antonopoulos, author of Mastering Bitcoin, argues in a clip that targeted investigation with probable cause and due process is acceptable, and that the real concern is surveillance of everyone all the time. Researchers have also published papers on ways Monero’s older rings could leak clues. If a coin you hold faces delisting, Bullrunners’ guide on how to protect coins before an exchange closes covers the practical steps.
What is FCMP++ and when does it arrive?
FCMP++ is the largest planned upgrade in Monero’s history, and as of the end of September 2026 it was still in testing with no main network date. Instead of hiding among 15 decoys, each spent coin would hide among all eligible outputs on the blockchain. The video compares it to hiding in a crowd of 100 million instead of a group of 16. It would also close some of the clues researchers have used to guess which ring member was real.
In August 2026, the security firm Trail of Bits, hired by the Monero charity MAGIC Grants, reviewed part of the cryptography behind FCMP++. According to the video, it found no high, medium or low severity issues, only minor informational notes. The video’s advice is to treat FCMP++ as coming, not here.
A three-question test for any coin you hold
The video turns Monero’s history into a test that works for any coin:
- Start at the launch. Monero’s story began with anger at an alleged head start. Ask who got the coins first, how much, and on what terms.
- Look for the strings. Monero’s launcher was forked out and its best-known leader stepped aside. Ask whether one person or company could rewrite the rules overnight, and what would stop them.
- Look past the code to the rule makers. A coin can be technically strong and still get squeezed off exchanges. Factor regulatory and listing risk in before you buy, not after.
What to watch next
For Monero specifically, two dates matter. The first is any main network date for FCMP++, which had none at the end of September 2026. The second is July 2027, when EU rules will stop regulated firms there from handling coins like Monero, changing where and how people in Europe can trade it. Beyond Monero, the three questions above are worth running against every coin you hold, starting with how its supply began.
Frequently asked questions
Who created Monero?
Monero is built on the CryptoNote white paper, written under the pseudonym Nicolas van Saberhagen. It was launched as BitMonero on the Bitcoin Talk forum on April 18, 2014 by a user called thankful_for_today, and a group including Riccardo Spagni forked the project away from him within weeks.
How does Monero keep transactions private?
According to the video, Monero uses stealth addresses to hide the receiver, ring signatures to hide the sender among decoys, and RingCT to hide the amount. Dandelion++, added in 2020, helps hide the internet address a transaction came from.
Why do exchanges delist Monero?
Exchanges are expected to know who their customers pay and are paid by, and Monero hides that information. Binance said on February 6, 2024 that it would drop Monero, and Kraken halted Monero trading in Europe on October 31, 2024, usually citing compliance.
Does Monero have a maximum supply?
No. Since 2022 Monero has used a tail emission that pays miners 0.6 XMR per block indefinitely, so supply keeps growing, though the growth rate shrinks every year.
What is FCMP++ in Monero?
FCMP++ is a planned upgrade that would let each spent coin hide among all eligible outputs on the blockchain instead of 15 decoys. As of the end of September 2026 it remained in testing with no main network date set.
Full video transcript
From the video's captions, lightly formatted. Captions can mishear names and numbers, so check figures against the article above.
I didn't create Monero. Um, I didn't create the code the first bit of code that created Monero. So, the Monero white paper is by a guy called Nicolas van Saberhagen. And that's a pseudonym. He doesn't I mean he exists obviously, but we don't know if it's one person or three people or, you know, some guy called Nicolas, some guy called Dan.
Yeah. Yeah. So, it's it's kind of Arsa Toshi, but like the white paper version. And then the actual implementation was written by again a pseudonym Antonio Juarez.
A white paper by someone no one can name, a code base by another fake name, and a launch by a forum user who was pushed out of his own project within weeks. That's how Monero began. And the coin it grew out of was accused of one of the sneakiest tricks in crypto, quietly mining most of its supply before anyone else was allowed in. Most people only know Monero as the privacy coin, the one exchange keeps delisting. But the story of how it was born explains a lot about why it survived, right?
And it's a story about what happens when a community decides nobody should own a coin, not even a person who launched it. And it's a story every holder on any coin can learn from, all right? So, that's why we're making the video because the question it raises is something we can apply to everything in your portfolio. As always, first this is not financial advice, please do your own research. Let's run that intro.
So, welcome back to the Bull Runner channel, guys. If you are new, please please hit the subscribe button. If you're not new, please check that you're subscribed cuz we know a lot of people have forgot to hit it. Now, my name's George Lee and we're going to get straight into this. So, the white paper you heard about at the start is called CryptoNote.
It's dated December 2012 with an updated version dated October 2013. Now, critics later argued those dates were fake. It was published under the name Nicolas van Saberhagen, all right? Nobody has ever proven who that is. Its big idea was that its Bitcoin's open ledger where anyone can follow the money was a flaw, not a feature.
It brought together tricks like ring signatures and one-time addresses, which we'll get to, so that payments could be easily linked. The first coin to use CryptoNote was actually called Bytecoin, and that's where things get murky. Bytecoin's blockchain claimed to have started in 2012, but it only became publicly known in March 2014. Critics including Riccardo Spagni, who actually went on to lead Monero, argued that the early history had actually been mined in secret, and that roughly 80% of the coins that would ever exist had already been created before the public could mine a single one. Now, picture a raffle where the organizers quietly handed themselves most of the tickets before announcing the draw.
Why does that matter so much? Because a pre-mine means the insiders can sell to everyone else later at whatever the price the market will pay. So, for coins that cost them almost nothing, it's one of the oldest tricks in crypto, and one of the first things worth checking on any coin. That's the accusation, and it has never been proven either way, but the accusation stuck, and it set up everything that happened next. It was the 18th of April 2014 when a user on the Bitcoin Talk forum called Thankful for Today launched a new coin based on the CryptoNote code, but they were starting from zero, so nobody got a head start.
He called it BitMonero. Here's Riccardo Spagni actually telling the story in a talk in 2018. Hear it from him himself.
To give you some indication, let's talk a little bit about how Monero got started um because it wasn't launched by me, contrary to popular belief. It was launched by a guy called Thankful for Today on Bitcoin Talk back in 2014.
The trouble started almost straight away, right? Thankful for today wanted to make changes to the community, and they didn't like it. And according to the people who took over, he simply wouldn't listen. So, they did something that sounds impossible in the normal business world. They actually took the project away from him.
They took it. Check this out.
And uh myself and six others decided to fork the project away from him um because he didn't want to listen to the community. Uh and so we're the stewards of the Monero project, which basically means we control like the GitHub repo and the domain. That's really all we control.
A fork in plain English means copying the code and carrying on without the original owner. It was messy. We can see that, right? The public fight on a forum, not a boardroom decision. Within weeks of launch, the community version one, and it actually took a new name, Monero, all right, which means coin in Esperanto, the invented international language.
So, that moment shaped everything. Monero has no company, no chief executive, and no founder who can pull the strings, because the person who launched it was forked out. Even Ricardo stepped down as lead maintainer in December 2019, and the project carried on. There's no development fund taken from each block, either, right? Instead, developers put up proposals on a community crowdfunding system, and then supporters donate to ones who want to build it.
Now, here's how the their own community film put it. Check this out.
Monero is It basically it's run like a charity. There is no company behind it. There's no pre-mine. There's no scammy like way for people to get rich. Um all of the Monero in existence were given in the past to a miner who was doing the accounting work to help support the network, just like in Bitcoin.
No company, no pre-mine, that's the part holders tend to skip. Every single token that exists was owned by mining from day one in public. Here's the question I wish I'd asked sooner about every coin I bought. Who got the coins first and how? It's amazing how often the answer changes and how you feel about holding it.
Our team will happily walk through that question with you, all right? If you just hit the link down below, you're going to get access to a free call. They're going to look each coin you hold, how its supply started, and what that might mean for you. Booking is simple. The descriptions open in links lead to a quick free training.
And simple, when you've watched it, press the button that appears beneath. Answer a handful of questions and then simply lock in a slot. Now, if you're watching on mobile, guys, press more below the titles to reveal it. Get it sorted while you're thinking of it, and then simply carry on. When you're back, I'll show you how Monero actually hides your money and why exchanges keep throwing it out.
So, on Bitcoin, anyone can see which address sent how much to which address, all right? Monero hides all three. Ricardo summed it up at the start of the same 2018 talk. Check this out.
So, Monero focuses on four privacy-enhancing aspects. The first thing is we use something called dual-key stealth addresses, because we want to hide hide where transactions are going to. The second thing is we use ring signatures, because we want to hide where transactions are coming from. Then we use something called Ring CT or Ring Confidential Transactions to hide the amount that's being transacted. And lastly, we want to hide the originating IP address of transactions.
In plain English, a stealth address means you give out just one public address, but every sender automatically turns it into a brand new one. Now, they turn it into a brand new one-time address so each payment lands somewhere different. Only you can tell those payments were meant for you. Ring signatures, the second piece that we'll we'll come to in a moment, Ring CT, the third piece, hides the amount and so nobody watching can actually see whether you sent five coins or 5,000. The last piece he mentioned, hiding where transactions come from on the internet, that was later actually handled by a system called Dandelion Plus Plus, which Monero added in 2020.
So, what's the point of all this? You're probably asking that, right? If you've got nothing to hide, what's the point? Well, Dr. Daniel Kim in that community film put it like this.
When you have a fiat bank account, you do not expect that your bank is going to post your monthly statement up on the bulletin board outside the bank for everybody to see. Right? But that is exactly the situation in Bitcoin. And it's not just the people out in your neighborhood who can see it, it's everybody. Everybody in the world can see uh who sent what to who and when.
Now, that's the privacy argument, but there's a second argument. That matters just as much for anyone holding a coin as money. It's called fungibility.
In contrast, Monero is fungible. Fungible just means that every unit of currency is indistinguishable from the other units, right? So, if I have 10 Monero, you have 10 Monero, and then, you know, we both trade the 10 Monero to other people, they still look like the 10 Monero. There's no history. It works just like a like a cash bill.
It works just like cash would you would think cash should work.
Now, here's why that matters, right? On a see-through blockchain, coin can carry its past with it. If a coin wants past through a hacked exchange, some services may refuse it even years later that is. So, if you did nothing wrong and it's years later, they can still refuse that. With Monero, there's no visible past to refuse.
So, how does it do it? Well, Dr. Kim explains the decoy trick. Check this.
One is ring signatures. So, in ring signatures, the sender of funds is lined up along with 10 other senders of funds and the only thing that you know happened in that transaction is one out of those 11 people sent money. So, it's as if every time you spend money, now you have 10 friends or 10 10 random people, 10 decoys. And all that you know cryptographically is one of the 11 of you sent the money. So, that protects the sender's identity.
How about the receiver's identity? Well, the receiver's Monero account does not appear unencrypted on the Monero blockchain. So, a one-time use address is what gets put on the blockchain. So, that protects the recipient's privacy.
One update after that film in August 22, Monero raised the number from 11 16. So, every coin you spend hides among 15 decoys. There's another part of Monero's design that actually goes way back to the white paper, right? Ricardo explained it why Monero fights specialized mining machines.
The main reason that Monero resists ASICs is because in the white paper, which wasn't written by me, it said that egalitarian mining is a goal.
So, this just means fair to everyone. In Bitcoin mining is dominated by warehouses full of specialized machines called ASICs. Monero changed its mining formula several times to keep those machines out. And in November 2019, it actually switched to a system called RandomX designed to run best on ordinary computer processors. The idea is simple, if anyone with a normal computer can mine, it's harder for a a big players to control the network.
As well, we'll see, right? That idea gets tested. Now, Monero's privacy makes regulators nervous. Exchanges are expected to know who their customers are paying and being paid by, but with Monero, they can't see it. In September 2020, the US tax authority, the IRS, offered up to $625,000 for tools to trace Monero.
Now, more exchanges delisted it, usually citing compliance. Binance said on the 6th of February 2024 that it would drop Monero. The Monero project's own account replied to them the exact same day. Kraken followed in Europe, halting Monero trading there on the 31st of October 2024. Then in August 2025, a project called Cubic pointed a huge amount of mining power at Monero, all right?
And actually managed to rewrite six blocks of its history. So, that's not the same as stealing coins, but it did show that a well-funded group could push the network around. Kraken paused Monero deposits for a while afterwards. Now, whether Cubic actually ever truly controlled more than half of the mining power is still debated, right? I can't tell you if that's factual truth.
But for a coin built around fair mining, it was an uncomfortable moment. Now, looking ahead, under new European anti-money laundering rules, banks, exchanges, and other crypto firms in the EU won't be allowed to handle coins like Monero from July 2027, and that's not that far away. Yet Monero is still here. It remains among the most recognized coins in crypto, still mined on ordinary computers, and still developed by volunteers. So, what comes next?
Well, the biggest upgrade in Monero's history is called FCMP++. Now, instead of hiding among 15 decoys, each coin you spend would hide among eligible output on the whole blockchain. So, think of the difference, right? Between hiding in a group of 16 people or hiding in a crowd of 100 million people. It would also close some of the clues researchers have used to use guess which ring member was real.
In August 2026, just gone, the security firm Trail of Bits, actually hired by the Monero charity Magic Grants, reviewed part of the cryptography behind it, and actually found no high, medium, or low severity issues, only very minor informational notes. So, by the end of September 2026, FCMP++ remained in testing, with no date set for the main network. So, treat it as coming, not here. There's one more design choice worth knowing, right? In mid-2022, Monero actually moved to what's called a tail emission.
Instead of stopping at a fixed cap like Bitcoin, it keeps paying miners a small fixed reward of 0.6 XMR per block forever. The idea is that miners will always be paid to secure the network, even if fees stay low. Now, critics point out it means the supply never stops growing, though the rate of growth shrinks every year. Supporters reply that a coin on which relies only on the fees to pay its miners is making a big bet on the future of Monero it chose not to make. Then there's the uncomfortable part, right?
Monero's privacy is used by criminals. Researchers have tracked its ransomware demands on the darknet markets, and that's the reason that regulators and exchanges keep backing away. So, if you hold it, that reputation and the risk of more delisting comes with it. Supporters answer that cash is also used by criminals, and cash is still legal. Andreas Antonopoulos, the author of Mastering Bitcoin, argued that the real question is what kind of surveillance we accept.
Watch this.
What we should be thinking about is this asymmetry of surveillance, meaning that I want systems where if there is probable cause and due process and a and a person who's doing things that as a society we don't want them doing, and you have the basis to to find that person, um you can find out, perhaps in retrospect, what they've done with their systems. Um that's not a bad thing.
His point is that targeted investigators with probable cause and due process are fine. What worries privacy supporters is surveillance of everyone all the time. So, supporters actually say privacy protects ordinary people from stalkers, thieves, and data leaks, and that a coin with a public history isn't really fair money at all. There are also technical questions, all right? Researchers have published papers on ways Monero's older rings could leak clues, and the Cubic episode showed its mining can be pushed around.
Upgrades like FCMP++ are the community's answer to the first. Both sides have a point. So, what does this whole story mean for whatever you hold? Well, try running any of them through the same test that Monero's history puts in front of you. All right, start at the launch.
Monero's story begins with anger at Bitcoin's alleged head start. So, look at who got any coins first supply and what terms. Then, look for the strings. Monero's first launch got forked out and its best known leader stepped aside. Very few projects can actually say no single person is in charge.
So, ask whether one person or company could rewrite the rules overnight and what would stop. And finally, look past the code to the rule makers. A coin can be technically brilliant and still get squeezed off exchanges. Now, that's a real risk and it belongs in your thinking before you buy. With Monero, the July 2027 date is Europe is one to keep in mind because it will change where and how people can trade it there.
Question for you in the comments, is privacy something you should pay for in crypto or do you think it brings more trouble than it's worth? Genuinely, let me know your answer, not just what you think I want to see. Hitting that subscribe is going to get you the untold backstory of more coins like this one, guys. As always, please, please, please stay bullish.
[music]
Education and commentary only, not financial advice. Crypto is volatile and you can lose money. Do your own research and speak to a qualified advisor before making investment decisions. Figures and quotes are as reported in the video on October 16, 2026 and may have changed since.


